ReplyPilot vs Mailbutler
Mailbutler is an add-on for Apple Mail, Gmail and Outlook with tracking, templates and AI Smart Replies. Here's an honest look at how ReplyPilot compares.
Price
ReplyPilot: $20/month flat, 14-day free trial, no card.
Mailbutler: Smart Replies on its top tier, listed at $11.
What Mailbutler does well
- Email tracking, signatures and templates
- Smart Compose and Smart Replies on the top tier
- Apple Mail, Gmail and Outlook add-on
Where ReplyPilot is different
- Reads new mail and prepares drafts automatically, in an approval queue
- Profession presets and tone sliders
- Approved-facts library so replies stay accurate
- Runs in the browser, nothing to install
Pick Mailbutler for tracking and templates on a budget. Pick ReplyPilot if you want every incoming email answered for you.
Mailbutler details are from its public pricing page (https://www.mailbutler.io/pricing) as checked in October 2026 and may have changed. Mailbutler is a trademark of its owner; ReplyPilot is not affiliated with it. Outlook support in ReplyPilot is coming soon.
Answer every lead while you're with a client.
Start your 14-day free trial, connect one inbox, and keep it in Draft all mode until you trust it.